• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Keystone Tacos: Authentic Carnitas & Flavorful Burritos in Sayre, PA

Keystone Tacos in Sayre, PA, offers a fresh, authentic taste of Mexican street food that truly stands out. Known for their tender carnitas and flavorful birria tacos, each dish feels thoughtfully prepared, often made to order, ensuring freshness and bold flavors. Customers praise the perfect balance in their nachos and the hearty, satisfying burritos that keep them coming back. The casual, walk-up setup adds to the charm, making it a convenient yet high-quality spot. Keystone Tacos bridges the gap between fast food and authentic Mexican cuisine, delivering memorable meals that leave a lasting impression.

Keystone Tacos at a glance

  • Address 142 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840, United States
  • Phone +1 570-890-9040
  • Restaurant type Taco restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Keystone Tacos: Reviews & Ratings

Joey Scarduzio
5

I was so pleased to find out about this place. And they did NOT disappoint!! Coming from Texas, I have been looking for good authentic carñitas. These guys hit it right on the head. 10/10. Will be back!

Trisha Cornell
5

Owners are great! I got the nachos and they were delicious perfect topping to chip ratio!!!! I'll be back!!

Katrina Roof
5

Probably the best burritos ever. 10/10 will be back.

chris sprague
5

I was passing through the area for work and was looking for lunch... I came across this place. I got the birria tacos and rice bowl... omg was it tasty... I will definitely be back! Sorry I didn't take any pics... the tacos didn't last long... lol

Ashley Gyurik
5

Interesting set up, Much like a walk up taco place. We got two burritos for about $20. There was a little bit of a wait for the food after ordering which leads me to believe that maybe they cook the meat fresh instead of leaving it in a warmer all day. Id say its a good in-between point between Taco bell and Angry Burrito

George Ballenstedt
5

We ordered Keystone Tacos, across from SAYRE Pudgies, for dinner tonight. Wife had two chicken tacos, and I had the grilled deluxe burrito. We each had chips and cheese, the chips are the best I’ve had. &27 total. Ready in 10 minutes. Everything was amazing. Highly recommend. 5 stars.

Carol
5

First time ordering from Keystone Tacos. Ordered steak tacos, duplex tacos, fajita and supreme nachos. All was VERY good. The supreme nachos were loaded with the good stuff, not slim pickings like Applebee's. Tacos and fajitas are a good size. Ordered online and was ready within a half hour for pick up. Ordering online was quick and easy. Super friendly owners. Will definitely order from these guys again!

Emily Morningstar
5

Ordered delivery, food arrived quick and hot! The food was Delicious! Birria Street tacos were spicy and very flavorful and the chicken quesadilla was cheesy and crispy on the edges and very tasty. Highly recommend! Gonna be ordering again soon.

Location

  • Keystone Tacos
    Keystone Tacos
    142 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840, United States Hotline: +1 570-890-9040

Nestled in the heart of Sayre, Pennsylvania, Keystone Tacos stands out as a genuine slice of authentic Mexican flavor. This unassuming walk-up spot at 142 S Keystone Ave has quickly earned a loyal following, especially from those craving traditional delights like carnitas, birria tacos, and hearty burritos. From the moment you step up to order, you sense the dedication to freshness—meats are often cooked to order, ensuring bold, vibrant flavors that elevate each dish beyond the typical fast-food experience.

One of the striking highlights at Keystone Tacos is their carnitas, which Texas native Joey Scarduzio praises as spot-on authentic, a rare find outside the Lone Star State. Their birria tacos and accompanying rice bowls deliver rich, savory depth that quickly vanish from plates—testament to their irresistible taste. Meanwhile, the burritos boast a satisfying balance of ingredients, perfectly wrapped and generously filled, winning high marks from customers like Katrina Roof.

The nachos here are another crowd-pleaser, celebrated for an excellent topping-to-chip ratio that prevents sogginess and maximizes flavor with each bite. The experience is enhanced by the approachable and friendly owners, making Keystone Tacos not just a stop for a meal, but a welcoming, joyful encounter with genuine Mexican culinary tradition.

For those navigating between quick-chain options and authentic street food, Keystone Tacos strikes a compelling balance—offering fresh, thoughtfully prepared dishes that feel both genuine and accessible. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this spot is well worth the visit, promising consistent quality and vibrant flavors that invite repeat visits.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Dine-in